#SETI - ALLTHINGSGEO

Space Exploration

12 Theories on Why Aliens Are Still Missing

By Jonathan Bala December 3, 2024

12 Theories on Why Aliens Are Still Missing

Despite the countless planets across the universe that could harbor life, we still have no concrete evidence of extraterrestrial civilizations. This mysterious silence, known as the Fermi Paradox, has led scientists to propose various theories — from aliens hiding in underground oceans to the possibility that they’ve been destroyed by climate change or their own technology. The absence of aliens forces us to question the conditions needed for life and intelligence to thrive.

Summary

Aliens might exist in parallel universes that are more conducive to life than ours.
Extraterrestrial life could survive in space without the need for planets.
Many alien species could be hidden in underground oceans on icy moons.
Super-Earths might imprison alien species with high gravity, making space exploration impossible.
Advanced civilizations might have transitioned into robotic societies that we’re not equipped to detect.
Humans may have already encountered aliens but failed to recognize them due to cognitive biases.
Expansive civilizations might inadvertently destroy others during their growth.
Advanced alien societies may have collapsed due to climate change or resource depletion.
Aliens could be purposefully avoiding us to minimize interaction with potentially hostile species.
The vast distances of space might make communication and travel impractical for even advanced beings.
Intelligent alien species might avoid sending detectable signals to ensure survival.
We could be among the earliest civilizations in the universe.

12 Theories on Why Aliens Are Still Missing — Deep space nebula and galaxies galaxies and stars the universe is full of stars 3D illustration

The Mystery of Missing Aliens

The question “Where is everybody?” was asked by physicist Enrico Fermi. This question captures the puzzling silence of the universe. There are billions of planets that could support life. But we haven’t found any evidence of alien civilizations. Here are twelve main ideas that try to explain why we haven’t found aliens yet.

We’re Looking in the Wrong Universe

One theory suggests that our universe may not be the most conducive to life. Researchers studying the multiverse hypothesis propose that certain universes might have better conditions for star and planet formation. In our universe, only 23% of ordinary matter transforms into stars, which might limit the chances of alien life emerging.

Multiverse theory explained in this study.

Table 1: Star Formation Across Universes

Universe Type	Dark Energy Density	Star Formation Rate
Hypothetical Optimized	Moderate	27% of matter
Our Universe	Low	23% of matter

Perhaps aliens are thriving in alternate realities, leaving our universe comparatively barren.

Aliens Don’t Live on Planets

Not all life needs a planetary home. A study published in Astrobiology theorizes that advanced civilizations could live in free-floating colonies in space. These structures, encased in protective shells, could use the greenhouse effect to maintain livable conditions without a planetary anchor.

This possibility expands our search criteria for alien life, urging us to explore space’s voids rather than focusing solely on planets.

Hidden in Underground Oceans

Subsurface oceans exist beneath the icy crusts of moons like Europa and Enceladus. These environments, protected from surface hazards like radiation and asteroid impacts, could harbor life.

NASA’s upcoming Europa Clipper mission aims to explore this potential by analyzing water plumes erupting from Europa’s surface. The findings could redefine how and where we search for extraterrestrial life.

Imprisoned on Super-Earths

Super-Earths, with masses up to 10 times that of Earth, present unique challenges. The immense gravitational pull on these planets would make space travel nearly impossible for their inhabitants.

Michael Hippke, an astrophysicist, argues that such civilizations might remain forever confined to their planets, unable to reach out to the stars.

Learn more about this here.

We’re Searching for the Wrong Signals

“Any civilization that invents radio will likely invent machines to surpass itself,” said futurist Seth Shostak. Advanced alien societies may have transitioned entirely into robotic beings, making them harder to detect with current technology.

We may need to adjust our strategies to find signs of machine intelligence rather than biological life.

Humans Are Distracted

Our cognitive biases and limited imagination could prevent us from recognizing alien life. A study demonstrated that participants often overlooked unusual objects when searching for specific ones. If aliens are fundamentally different from us, we might fail to notice their presence entirely.

Civilizational Growth Destroys Others

Alexander Berezin’s controversial theory suggests that any interstellar civilization might inadvertently destroy lesser species as it expands. This destruction could happen unintentionally, similar to humans clearing forests for development without considering the insects and animals displaced.

Climate Change Kills Advanced Societies

As civilizations grow and exploit their planet’s resources, they may trigger catastrophic climate changes. Adam Frank’s simulations reveal that most advanced societies collapse under the weight of their own success unless they adopt sustainable practices early.

More details on sustainability can be found here.

Table 2: Outcomes of Civilizations in Climate Models

Scenario	Outcome	Survival Rate
Unchecked Resource Use	Planetary Collapse	25%
Early Sustainability	Stable, Long-Term Survival	75%

This raises the possibility that alien civilizations have already perished due to their inability to adapt.

Aliens Avoid Contact

Advanced civilizations might intentionally avoid us. The Zoo Hypothesis suggests that Earth could be part of a cosmic experiment, with aliens observing us from afar without interference. This could explain the lack of direct communication or evidence.

The Universe Is Too Vast

The immense distances between stars and galaxies create significant barriers to communication and travel. Even with advanced technology, it might take thousands of years for messages to traverse the cosmos, making real-time interaction impractical.

Intelligent Silence

Sending out signals could expose alien civilizations to potential threats. By remaining silent, they might be protecting themselves from hostile species. This theory emphasizes the importance of caution when broadcasting Earth’s presence into space.

We’re Among the First

If intelligent life is exceptionally rare, humanity might be one of the earliest civilizations to develop. This would place the responsibility of shaping interstellar exploration and contact squarely on our shoulders.

Facts

The term Fermi Paradox originates from a casual lunch discussion among scientists in 1950.
Radio telescopes like the Arecibo Observatory have been used for decades to search for extraterrestrial signals.
The Voyager spacecraft carries a Golden Record, a time capsule intended for any aliens that might find it.

References

#Aliens, #FermiParadox, #SpaceExploration, #ExtraterrestrialLife, #Multiverse, #EuropaClipper, #SuperEarths, #SETI, #SpaceScience, #Astrobiology, #ClimateChange, #ZooHypothesis, #MachineIntelligence, #Astronomy, #CosmicMystery

Keep Reading

Space Exploration

Celebrating the Last Arecibo Message: Humanity’s Boldest Signal to the Stars

By Jonathan Bala November 25, 2024

Celebrating the Last Arecibo Message: Humanity’s Boldest Signal to the Stars

The Arecibo Message remains a defining milestone in humanity’s quest to communicate with extraterrestrial civilizations. Commemorating its 50th anniversary, “The Last Arecibo Message” honors the observatory’s legacy and highlights the enduring human curiosity to explore the cosmos.

Summary

The Arecibo Message was humanity’s first deliberate attempt at Messaging Extraterrestrial Intelligence (METI), transmitted on November 16, 1974, from Puerto Rico’s Arecibo Observatory.
The message was a binary-encoded pictorial signal designed by Frank Drake, with contributions from Carl Sagan and others.
It targeted Messier 13 (M13), a globular star cluster approximately 25,000 light-years away in the Hercules constellation.
Encoded within the 1679-bit message were basic scientific principles, DNA structure, human anatomy, and Earth’s location in the Solar System.
The Arecibo Observatory collapsed in December 2020, a tragic end to its groundbreaking contributions to radio astronomy.
To mark the 50th anniversary of the original message, the Boriken Voyagers, a team from Puerto Rico, designed “The Last Arecibo Message” during the Arecibo Message Global Challenge.
Their updated message emphasizes advances in knowledge, humanity’s curiosity, and our place in the universe.
The ongoing debate surrounding SETI/METI focuses on caution and ethics in broadcasting humanity’s presence to potentially unknown civilizations.

Introduction

The Arecibo Message stands as one of the boldest gestures of humanity’s yearning to connect beyond Earth. Sent from the Arecibo Observatory in 1974, this brief binary signal was humanity’s first organized communication aimed at extraterrestrial intelligence. Its purpose was not only to showcase human knowledge but to demonstrate the power of our technologies and our curiosity about the universe.

The original Arecibo Message was an ambitious project led by Frank Drake, inventor of the Drake Equation, which estimates the number of intelligent extraterrestrial civilizations in the galaxy. Collaborating with prominent scientists, including Carl Sagan, the team created a 1679-bit binary message—a deliberate selection of two prime numbers to simplify interpretation by potential alien intelligences.

Contents of the Original Message

Category	Description
Numbers	Binary representation of numbers 1 through 10
Atomic Numbers	Atomic numbers for H, C, N, O, and P, the elements in DNA
DNA Structure	Chemical formulas and double-helix representation
Human Figure	A stick figure with average height and Earth’s population in 1974
Solar System	Schematic showing the Sun and planets, highlighting Earth
Arecibo Observatory	Diagram of the transmitter and its physical dimensions

This carefully curated message lasted a mere three minutes, broadcasting with a power of 20 gigawatts toward the M13 cluster, home to approximately 300,000 stars.

The Arecibo Observatory

The Arecibo Observatory in Puerto Rico was more than a transmitter; it was a global hub of astronomical innovation. For over 50 years, its iconic 305-meter dish conducted groundbreaking research, from discovering the first binary pulsar to mapping near-Earth asteroids.

Tragically, the observatory collapsed in December 2020, marking the end of an era for radio astronomy. Despite this loss, the legacy of the Arecibo Message endures as a beacon of what humanity can achieve.

The Last Arecibo Message

In 2018, the Arecibo Message Global Challenge called on students worldwide to design a new interstellar message. Among the participants, the Boriken Voyagers from Puerto Rico stood out. Their design, later named “The Last Arecibo Message,” updates the original with refined content to reflect advancements in mathematics, astronomy, and human culture.

Key Elements of the Updated Message

Section	Content
Mathematics	Constants like π, Euler’s number, and the speed of light
Astronomy	A detailed map of the Milky Way Galaxy and Earth’s location
Humanity	Modern population figures, anatomical details, and cultural symbols
Solar System	Enhanced representation with accurate planetary sizes and the Earth-Moon system

The Boriken Voyagers aim to continue the observatory’s legacy, celebrating both its contributions and humanity’s innate curiosity to explore the unknown.

SETI and METI: Progress and Ethical Considerations

The fields of Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) and Messaging Extraterrestrial Intelligence (METI) have evolved significantly since the original message. Technological advancements have improved our ability to both detect signals and transmit messages, leading to debates over the risks and benefits of deliberate broadcasts.

Cautious Optimism
Proponents argue that sending messages reflects humanity’s natural desire to explore and communicate. The Last Arecibo Message, for instance, represents a thoughtful balance of scientific and cultural content.

Skeptical Concerns
Critics warn of the potential dangers of revealing Earth’s location to unknown civilizations, citing examples like the speculative series The Three-Body Problem. Such narratives highlight the possibility of contact with hostile intelligences.

Facts About the Arecibo Message

The binary format was chosen because mathematics is considered a universal language.
The M13 cluster was selected not only for its proximity but for its age and density, increasing the likelihood of intelligent life.
The message’s 20-gigawatt signal was equivalent to the output of 10 trillion household lightbulbs!
Arecibo’s radio transmissions also included radar mapping of Venus, detecting the first binary pulsar, and tracking asteroids.

The Arecibo Observatory has collapsed. This event has inspired projects to honor its legacy. One such project is “The Last Arecibo Message.” It has also started new discussions. These discussions focus on the ethics of METI. METI stands for Messaging Extraterrestrial Intelligence. It involves sending messages to aliens. People are talking about humanity’s role in this area. We could be both senders and receivers of communication from aliens.

References

#AreciboMessage, #SETI, #METI, #InterstellarCommunication, #Astronomy, #AreciboObservatory, #SpaceExploration, #CosmicCuriosity, #BorikenVoyagers, #HumanLegacy, #ExtraterrestrialLife, #Astrophysics, #GalacticExploration, #TeamworkInScience, #SpaceInnovation

Keep Reading

Space Exploration

The Wow! Signal Explained: It Was Hydrogen All Along

By Jonathan Bala August 21, 2024

The Wow! Signal Explained: It Was Hydrogen All Along

Summary

1977: The Wow! Signal was detected by the Big Ear radio telescope at Ohio State University.
Frequency: The signal was near the frequency of neutral hydrogen (1,420 MHz).
Name Origin: Named “Wow!” after astronomer Jerry Ehman’s reaction to the signal on a computer printout.
Signal Details: The signal lasted 72 seconds, matching the telescope’s observing window.
Interpretations: Initially thought to be a possible technosignature, indicating an extraterrestrial origin.
New Research: Suggests the signal was caused by a natural astrophysical event, not ETI.
Arecibo Wow! Project: Recent data from the Arecibo Radio Telescope indicates the signal likely came from the brightening of neutral hydrogen clouds.
Astrophysical Explanation: The brightening could be caused by a magnetar flare or a soft gamma repeater (SGR) interacting with hydrogen clouds.
Implications: The Wow! Signal is an example of how natural phenomena can mimic technosignatures.
New Understanding: This research helps explain the rarity of the Wow! Signal and identifies potential sources of false positives in the search for extraterrestrial intelligence.

The Wow! Signal: A Mysterious Event from the Depths of Space

On August 15, 1977, the Big Ear radio telescope, located at Ohio State University, detected a signal that has since become legendary in the field of astronomy and the search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI). This signal, lasting precisely 72 seconds, was so extraordinary that when astronomer Jerry R. Ehman reviewed the data, he circled the sequence “6EQUJ5” on the printout and wrote a single word beside it: “Wow!” This simple reaction gave the signal its iconic name—the Wow! Signal.

The frequency of the Wow! Signal was a key factor in the excitement it generated. It was located near 1,420 MHz, the natural emission frequency of neutral hydrogen. This frequency, known as the hydrogen line, is significant because hydrogen is the most abundant element in the universe, and many astronomers believe that any extraterrestrial civilization attempting to communicate across interstellar distances would use it.

Hydrogen’s frequency is a natural universal constant, making it an ideal candidate for interstellar communication. The fact that the Wow! Signal appeared near this frequency led many to speculate that it could be a message from an extraterrestrial intelligence (ETI).

The Wow! Signal Explained It Was Hydrogen All Along — This simple diagram shows how the Wow! Signal was created and detected. A radiative source, like a magnetar or a soft gamma repeater, is behind a cloud of cold neutral hydrogen. A magnetar is a type of neutron star with a powerful magnetic field. A soft gamma repeater is a type of star that emits bursts of gamma rays. The energy from the source excites the HI cloud, making it suddenly brighter. This brightening can be seen from Earth. Image Credit: Méndez et al. 2024.

Understanding the Signal

The Wow! Signal stood out for several reasons:

Strength: The signal was strong and narrowband, indicating that it was not a random cosmic noise.
Duration: It lasted exactly 72 seconds, matching the window during which the Big Ear telescope could observe it due to the Earth’s rotation.
Non-recurrence: Despite numerous follow-up observations, the signal was never detected again, adding to its mystery.

These characteristics made the Wow! Signal unique and fueled speculation about its origin. Was it a signal from another civilization? Or was there a more mundane explanation?

For decades, the Wow! Signal remained one of the most tantalizing mysteries in astronomy. Various explanations were proposed, ranging from reflections off space debris to signals from a distant planet or star. However, none of these explanations were entirely satisfactory, and the signal’s origin remained elusive.

The Ohio State University Big Ear radio telescope, which detected the Wow! Signal, was part of the university’s SETI program, which operated from 1973 to 1995. This program is the longest-running SETI program in history, and the Wow! Signal is its most famous discovery.

The Big Ear radio telescope was a significant instrument in the search for extraterrestrial intelligence. Built in the 1960s, it was initially designed for a different purpose—mapping the radio sky. However, it was later repurposed for SETI, and it played a crucial role in the search for signals from other civilizations.

The Big Ear was a stationary telescope that used the Earth’s rotation to scan the sky. As the Earth turned, the telescope would sweep across the sky, allowing it to observe a broad area. The Wow! Signal was detected during one of these sweeps, leading to its unique 72-second duration.

The 6EQUJ5 Code

The sequence “6EQUJ5” that Jerry Ehman circled on the printout is not a hidden message but rather a representation of the signal’s intensity over time. Each character in the sequence corresponds to a specific intensity level, with numbers representing lower intensities and letters representing higher ones.

The signal started at a low intensity (“6”), quickly peaked (“EQU”), and then faded away (“J5”). This pattern, combined with the signal’s frequency and duration, made it stand out from the background noise and captured Ehman’s attention.

After the Wow! Signal was detected, astronomers eagerly awaited its repetition. However, despite numerous attempts to find the signal again, it never reappeared. The lack of repetition only deepened the mystery and led to a wide range of speculations about its origin.

Some suggested that the signal was a one-time event, possibly a deliberate transmission from a distant civilization. Others speculated that it was a natural phenomenon, though no known natural sources could account for all the characteristics of the Wow! Signal.

The New Hypothesis: Hydrogen Brightening

In recent years, the mystery of the Wow! Signal has taken a new turn with research led by Abel Méndez from the Planetary Habitability Laboratory at the University of Puerto Rico at Arecibo. This research suggests that the Wow! Signal may have a natural astrophysical explanation.

The Arecibo Wow! project is a recent effort to understand the Wow! Signal by analyzing data from the now-defunct Arecibo Radio Telescope. Between 2017 and 2020, the Arecibo telescope observed signals similar to the Wow! Signal, though less intense. These observations provided new insights into the possible origin of the Wow! Signal.

Méndez and his team proposed that the Wow! Signal was caused by the sudden brightening of a cloud of neutral hydrogen in space. This brightening could have been triggered by a magnetar flare or a soft gamma repeater (SGR), both of which are known to emit bursts of energy that can interact with hydrogen clouds.

According to the research, the Wow! Signal was likely the result of a specific alignment between a radiative source (such as a magnetar) and a cloud of neutral hydrogen. The energy from the source would stimulate the emission of the hydrogen line, causing the cloud to brighten suddenly and produce a signal detectable from Earth.

This hypothesis explains several key aspects of the Wow! Signal:

Frequency: The signal’s frequency matched the hydrogen line because it was caused by hydrogen emission.
Strength: The signal was strong because of the rare and powerful interaction between the radiative source and the hydrogen cloud.
Non-recurrence: The signal was a one-time event due to the precise alignment required for it to occur.

Supporting Evidence from Arecibo

The Arecibo telescope’s observations between 2017 and 2020 detected similar narrowband signals near the hydrogen line, though less intense than the Wow! Signal. These signals came from multiple locations and were consistent with the hypothesis of hydrogen brightening.

Table 1 below shows a comparison between the Wow! Signal and the Arecibo detections:

Characteristic	Wow! Signal (1977)	Arecibo Signals (2017-2020)
Frequency	Near hydrogen line	Near hydrogen line
Intensity	High	Lower
Duration	72 seconds	Variable
Source	Unknown	Multiple locations
Explanation	Hydrogen brightening	Hydrogen brightening

The rarity of the Wow! Signal can be explained by the rarity of the required alignment. The radiative source, hydrogen cloud, and Earth-based observer must be precisely aligned for the signal to be detected. This alignment is rare, which is why the Wow! Signal has not been observed again.

The researchers were able to identify the hydrogen clouds that could have produced the signal, but they have not yet identified the radiative source. The source is likely much more distant than the clouds, making it difficult to pinpoint.

The discovery that the Wow! Signal may have a natural explanation has significant implications for the search for extraterrestrial intelligence. It highlights the importance of considering natural astrophysical phenomena when analyzing potential technosignatures. The Wow! Signal, long considered one of the best candidates for a signal from another civilization, may be an example of how nature can mimic the signals that SETI scientists are looking for.

Table 2: Natural vs. Artificial Explanations

Explanation Type	Key Characteristics	Example
Artificial (ETI)	Narrowband, non-repeating, technologically feasible	Technosignature signals
Natural (Astrophysical)	Broad or narrowband, possibly repeating, linked to known astrophysical phenomena	Hydrogen brightening, pulsars

The Wow! Signal is still a mystery, and we may never solve it completely. New research shows it was probably a natural event, not a message from aliens. This signal reminds us that the universe is very complex. It also shows how hard it is to search for extraterrestrial intelligence, which means finding life beyond Earth. As we keep exploring space, we have to stay open-minded. Some signals we find might come from natural sources, not from other civilizations.

Hashtags

#WowSignal, #Astronomy, #SETI, #HydrogenLine, #Arecibo, #Astrophysics, #InterstellarCommunication, #CosmicMysteries

Keep Reading