Starlink Suffers Setback: FCC Rejects SpaceX’s Request for Mobile Satellite Service Spectrum

The Complete Story

SpaceX’s ambitious plan for its next-generation Starlink constellation has encountered a hurdle. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) recently dismissed SpaceX’s request to utilize specific mobile satellite services (MSS) spectrum for Gen2 Starlink. This decision throws a wrench into SpaceX’s deployment timeline and reignites discussions about spectrum allocation in the burgeoning mega-constellation era.

SpaceX’s Vision for Gen2 Starlink

Gen2 Starlink promises significant advancements over the current constellation. With up to 7,500 satellites already approved by the FCC in Ku- and Ka-bands, Gen2 boasts faster speeds, lower latency, and the ability to serve more customers in underserved areas. To achieve these goals, SpaceX sought to leverage additional spectrum beyond the Ku- and Ka-bands. Specifically, the company requested access to spectrum allocated to existing MSS operators like Globalstar and Dish in the 1.6/2.4 GHz bands, 2 GHz bands, and the 2020-2025 MHz Earth-to-space band.

The FCC’s Reasoning for Dismissal

The FCC’s denial hinged on the lack of existing regulations to accommodate an additional MSS system within the requested bands. The current framework, established in 2007, caters to the functionalities of the original MSS systems proposed back in 1994. The FCC deemed this framework inadequate for the technological advancements and the sheer number of satellites envisioned by SpaceX’s Gen2 Starlink. They emphasized the need for a formal rulemaking process to establish new regulations that consider the complexities of large LEO constellations like Starlink.

SpaceX Pushes for Modernization

While the FCC’s decision presents a setback, SpaceX isn’t backing down without a fight. The company petitioned the FCC to update its framework for “Big LEO” systems. This proposal advocates for a streamlined processing round that considers all pending applications for MSS systems in the 1.6/2.4 GHz band, including those from Globalstar, SpaceX, and Kepler Communications. Essentially, SpaceX argues that the current framework is outdated and hinders innovation in the satellite internet domain.

Looking Ahead: Implications and Unresolved Questions

The FCC’s decision and SpaceX’s response raise critical questions about regulating the future of large LEO constellations. Here are some key takeaways:

• The Need for Updated Regulations: The Starlink saga highlights the urgent need for updated regulations to govern the deployment and operation of large LEO constellations. Existing frameworks might not adequately address issues like spectrum allocation, debris mitigation, and potential interference with existing communication infrastructure.
• Balancing Innovation and Competition: Finding the right balance between fostering innovation from companies like SpaceX and protecting the interests of established satellite operators like Globalstar and Dish is crucial. The FCC’s future decisions will influence how this balance is achieved.
• Potential Delays for Gen2 Starlink: The dismissal could lead to delays in SpaceX’s Gen2 Starlink deployment timeline. The company will need to navigate the new rulemaking process or explore alternative spectrum options to achieve its full potential.

The FCC’s decision is a reminder that the space industry is not just about technological advancements, but also about navigating a complex regulatory landscape. How SpaceX responds to this hurdle and how the FCC shapes the future regulatory framework will significantly impact the development of large LEO constellations and the future of satellite internet access.